AI search attribution is messy. Someone asks ChatGPT for options, asks three follow-ups, searches your name on Google a day later and books a call. Your analytics calls that “branded search” or “direct.” The AI that did the persuading gets no credit.

You won’t fix that with a better dashboard. You fix it by asking.

The two-question fix for AI search attribution

SEO Harpreet Singh described the setup he relies on, in a conversation with Edward Sturm:

  1. “How did you hear about us?” on every form, booking page and checkout, with “AI assistant (ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, etc.)” as an option.
  2. If they pick AI: “What did you ask it?” as a short text box.

The first question tells you how much business AI is sending. The second tells you which questions you’re winning, and those become the topics you write about next. Harpreet said that without that field he couldn’t have justified the work.

Self reported attribution: why it beats guessing here

Self reported attribution means customers tell you where they came from. It has flaws: people forget, pick the first option or name the last thing they saw. But for AI search it fills a gap analytics can’t. Many AI visits don’t arrive as a clean referral, and many AI-influenced buyers arrive later through a search for your name.

Use both views together: analytics for clicks, the form for influence.

Answer options that give AI its own slot

Keep the list short and plain:

  • Google search
  • AI assistant (ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude, etc.)
  • Friend or colleague
  • Social media
  • Review site (Google, Yelp, G2, etc.)
  • Other (tell us)

Put AI as its own option, not inside “search.” Randomize the order if your form tool allows it so “Google” doesn’t win by being first.

Asking after the sale instead

If you can’t add a field to your forms, ask after the sale: a one-question email or a question on the onboarding call. Log answers in your CRM next to the deal value so you can total revenue by source each quarter.

Reading your AI search attribution results

  • Monthly: count AI answers and the deals attached to them.
  • Quarterly: compare the share of revenue that came via AI with last year’s same quarter.
  • Always: read the “what did you ask it?” answers. If people keep asking for “a bookkeeper for restaurants,” that’s a page to build (see brand positioning for AI search).

For visibility (are you in the answers at all), pair this with AI visibility tracking.

FAQ

Where should the attribution question go?
On every point where someone becomes a lead: contact forms, booking pages, checkout and phone intake scripts. Make it required but short.

How do I track revenue from AI search?
Attach the answer to the deal in your CRM, then total deals by source each quarter. For a fuller view of measurement, see how to measure GEO and AI search visibility.

Is self reported attribution accurate?
Not perfectly. Treat it as a strong signal, not an exact count, and watch the trend over time rather than any single month.

Should I ask what customers typed into the AI?
Yes. It’s optional for them, but the answers show which questions recommend you and where you’re missing.

Can analytics show ChatGPT traffic?
Some, when people click a link in an answer. Much AI influence never shows up as a click, which is why the form matters.

Why we just ask

Here’s the reality. I’ve built, scaled, and sold three companies, generated over $85 million in the last seven years in my own companies. In all three, the most reliable attribution data we ever had came from asking customers directly. Analytics loses most AI referrals: people read an answer, then search your name or type your address.

With more than 800 million weekly ChatGPT users reported by OpenAI in October 2025, that gap is too big to ignore. Two questions on a form close most of it.

Want us to set it up?

We’ll add the two questions to your forms, booking pages and checkout, set up a simple monthly report, and turn the “what did you ask it?” answers into your next pages. You approve every change. Why now: every month without the field is a month of AI customers you can’t count. See our AEO service.

Want proof AI is sending you customers?

Book a call and we’ll add the two questions and read your first month of answers with you.

Book a Search Strategy Call